By 2015, amid ongoing concerns from artists, both Prince and Neil Young removed their entire catalogues from Spotify. Young removed his music because he believed the sound on the website was sub-quality and was working on his own rival service. Financially, things were also still a little iffy, with Spotify reporting increasing losses of $197 million (£148m) in 2015, despite record revenues of $2.2 billion (£1.65bn). The same year also saw the birth of rival Tidal, an artist-owned streaming service founded by Jay-Z, which, although strongly supported by the artist community, has failed to reach the masses in the way that Spotify has.