US coins and bills worth far more than their face value
Worth a pretty penny
Avid collectors of American notes and coins will often pay eye-watering sums for desirable items in mint condition. From the pennies and dollar bills you may just find lurking in your wallet or purse to historically important rarities that can fetch millions, read on to discover the US cash worth considerably more than its face value. All dollar amounts in US dollars.
Genesis Widick at English Wikipedia [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
2005-P Kansas state 'In God We Rust' quarter: up to $100
A number of 2005 Kansas state quarter coins, minted in Philadelphia, were incorrectly imprinted with the motto "In God we Rust" as a build-up of grease in the die meant the "T" of "trust" didn't print. These so-called "error coins," which are in circulation right now, can be worth anything up to $100 apiece depending on their condition.
Repeat serial number bills: up to $160
It's always a good idea to check the serial numbers on the bills in your wallet or purse: after all, fancy serial numbers can command surprisingly high prices. For example: so-called "repeater" and "super-repeater" notes, which feature serial numbers that replicate the same one, two or three digits, can sell for up to $160, and sometimes significantly more, on eBay and similar auction sites.
Courtesy darker-shadows/eBay
2006 misprint dollar bill: $200
It's not just spelling mistakes that can make bank notes more valuable. Printing errors can range from bills with incorrectly colored seals and orientations that are off to upside down or double-printed serial numbers. By way of example, this 2006 dollar bill features a double-printed serial number and sold on eBay for just under $200. The weirder the misprint, the more valuable the note is likely to be.
1982 Roosevelt no mint mark dime: up to $300
There's a likelihood that this coin could show up in your change, so look out for it. All US coins should have a mint mark, be it P for the Philadelphia Mint, S for the San Francisco Mint, D for the Denver Mint, or W for the West Point Mint. However, a number, thought to be no more than 150,000, of 1982 Roosevelt dimes were released in 1982 without a mark. If you spot one that lacks a mint mark next to the year stamp, it could be worth up to $300.
1928 red seal $2 bill: up to $380
While rarely used, the $2 bill remains in circulation, though relatively few are printed these days. While they aren't worth much more than their face value, the red seal $2 notes that were issued in 1928 could be worth something. These crisply immaculate bills can fetch decent prices at auction – a particularly fine example sold on eBay for just under $380.
2004-D Wisconsin state extra leaf quarter coin: up to $400
Thousands of Wisconsin state extra leaf quarters were issued in error by the Denver Mint in 2004. There are two varieties of the quarter available to find, which is incorrect due to the presence of an extra cornstalk leaf in its design.
Variety one is the low leaf version, which depicts an arched leaf jutting out sideways on the reverse of the coin, while variety two is the high leaf version, which shows an additional leaf poking out of the cheese wheel that touches the corn husk leaf. These coins can be worth up to $400 each – so if you find one in your change, make sure you hang onto it!
1972-P doubled die Lincoln penny coin: up to $500
An estimated 20,000 examples of the 1972 doubled die pennies slipped through the net, many of which are still in circulation. One of the most common minting errors, doubled die coins are created when the die imprints a misaligned image on the coin, giving the lettering and numbers a blurred finish. The fuzzy effect is pretty pronounced on these Abe Lincoln cents, and they're worth up to $500 each.
Courtesy jscabani1988/eBay
Star serial number bills: up to $500
Another type of fancy serial number bill is the so-called "star note," which features an asterisk at the end of the serial number. These are printed to replace faulty notes and, since no two serial numbers can be the same, an asterisk is swapped in at the end of the serial number in place of a letter. Most aren't worth a lot more than their face value, but the most valuable can fetch up to $500, so it's worth keeping your eyes peeled.
1999-P Wide AM Lincoln memorial penny coin: up to $500
In 1999, the Philadelphia Mint issued around 400 Lincoln Memorial pennies with a space between the letters "A" and "M" in the word "America" on the coin's reverse side. This subtle spacing error is the giveaway clue that you could have something of value on your hands. Other coins issued have virtually no space between the letters, which look like they're touching. The so-called "Wide AM" coins are now worth around $500 apiece.
1955-P doubled die Lincoln penny coin: up to $2,000
Up to 24,000 doubled die pennies were released into circulation by the Philadelphia Mint in 1955. Many of these ended up being spent on packs of cigarettes in New England vending machines: the price per pack was 23 cents, but the machines could only take quarters, so the pennies were added to the packs to even up the price. These circulated coins, which feature the telltale blurred lettering and numbers on the reverse, can be worth up to $2,000 each.
Solid serial number bills: up to $4,500
Notes with serial numbers made up of identical digits are rare, with only one in 11 million bills printed boasting this type of detail. As a result, they're worth big bucks. Considered lucky by some, this dollar bill, which has a serial number entirely comprised of sevens, sold recently on eBay for $600. Even more impressively, a 2006 $100 bill with a ones-only serial number was available recently on the CoolSerialNumbers site for $4,500.
Courtesy US Rare Currency
Ladder serial number bills: $5,000+
Notes that have serial numbers with digits that ascend or descend are also pretty prized. Called "ladder bills," the most sought-after examples are bills that feature the so-called "perfect" ladder serial numbers: 12345678 and 87654321. Unsurprisingly, these notes are exceedingly scarce and represent only one-in-96-million bills printed, meaning they can sell for big bucks.
2000-P Sacagawea transitional error dollar coin: up to $15,000
Five Sacagawea commemorative dollars have been found with transitional errors, according to Mint Error News. These mistakes occur when a coin is struck with a different metal composition from what has previously been used, before being fed into a coin press for the current year. These mega-rare coins can be worth up to $15,000 and, who knows, there might even be more of them out there...
Low serial number bills: up to $15,000
Check your bills for low serial numbers, as these could make you some serious money. According to the experts, a redesigned $100 bill with the serial number 00000001 could fetch anywhere between $10,000 and $15,000. Other typically low serial number bills (00000100 or lower) can be worth a little less, realizing up to $1,000.
Courtesy Stack's Bowers Galleries
1933 $10 silver certificate bill: up to $70,500
Dubbed “The King of Silvers” by collectors in the know, the 1933 $10 silver certificate had a print run of 216,000, but only 156,000 were ever released. Very few survive to this day and due to its "one-year type" status, these remarkable notes are tremendously valuable. While used examples in good condition can fetch up to $5,200, the finest grades can sell for as much as $70,500.
Courtesy Stack's Bowers Galleries
2021 Liberty American Gold Eagle coin: $100,000
In September, Stack's Bowers Galleries sold the very first 1-ounce American Gold Eagle that was struck last year. Featuring the new eagle portrait by the artist Jennie Norris, the coin broke records when it fetched $100,000 – more than triple the previous record for a 1-ounce American Gold Eagle coin, which was $29,700.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1969-S doubled die Lincoln penny: $126,500
You'll have hit the jackpot if you discover one of these babies in your change. Astonishingly, only 50 of the 1969-S doubled die Lincoln pennies escaped the mint and made it into circulation – and it's safe to say that their value far exceeds one cent.
Michigan-based collector Michael Tremonti found one in 2007 while searching through a 50-coin roll and it was later valued at a sensational $126,500. Another sample of the coin sold in auction for $85,100 in 2007. It pays to check your change, people...
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1902 Alaska $5 Bill: $246,750
If you've got some very old bills stashed away at home, you might want to check for state-issued notes. After all, many of these are worth significantly more than their face value.
This Alaskan banknote, for instance, was printed during the state's famous Klondike Gold Rush and was among the first $5 bills issued by the First National Bank of Fairbanks. It was sold in 2012 by Heritage Auctions for an incredible $246,750.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1855-S $3 Gold coin: $264,000
According to Heritage Auctions: "when it comes to finest known, few coins in the three-dollar gold series hold that status with as much clout and significance" as this 1855-S example, which sold for a record high of $264,000 in September.
With a Mint State classification, this coin is one of just seven in such good condition. Its final sale price was substantially higher than the previous record for a similar 1855-S, which realized $64,625 at auction back in 2017.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1943-P/-S Lincoln copper wheat penny coin: up to $282,000
During World War II, pennies were struck in zinc-coated steel, with copper reserved for the war effort. That said, a tiny batch was accidentally minted in copper, and it's believed that around 20 of the erroneous Philadelphia and San Francisco-minted coins are floating around today.
In 1947, 16-year-old Don Lutes Jr discovered one of the coins in his lunch money change. Lutes kept it until 2019, when he sold it at auction for a whopping $204,000, with Heritage Auctions describing the coin as "the Holy Grail of mint errors."
So how can you tell if you've got one of the incredibly rare 1943 copper pennies? Use a magnet. Steel pennies will stick, while the valuable copper rarities won't.
Courtesy Morton & Eden/Instagram
1652 New England shilling: $351,912
First minted in around 1652, this silver shilling is one of the earliest coins from Colonial New England. There are just a few-dozen known to exist, and while a shilling in 1650 is the equivalent of about $7 today, this example (pictured) sold for a whopping $351,912 at auction in November 2021, smashing past its original $300,000 estimate.
The coin was originally minted in Boston but ended up being discovered a long way from home in a candy tin in Northumberland, England.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1860-S Gold $3 coin: $360,000
In September this year, this 1860-S gold $3 coin set a new auction record for the series when it sold for $360,000. According to the auction listing, the coin – which came from the collection of coin collector Harry Bass – "has long, established recognition as the finest known [1860-S $3 gold piece], and by a large margin." It has come up for auction only twice in at least a century.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
2004 Del Monte $20 bill: $396,000
Say hello to a truly unique 2004 $20 bill, which had a Del Monte banana sticker attached to it before being printed with its security numbering. Prior to being sold at auction, the one-of-a-kind note was valued at $57,500, which is nearly 3,000 times its face value. However, it defied all expectations in January 2021, when it sold in auction for a whopping $396,000 – a record price for a banknote with an error.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1833 Quarter Eagle $2 coin: $408,000
It's been estimated that just five or six 1833 Quarter Eagle $2 proofs exist, and the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) has certified just one: this example that sold for $408,000 in September this year. According to Heritage Auctions, many of the other copies were melted down.
On the reverse, the coin has the traditional US motto "E PLURIBUS UNUM" ("one from many"), which was discontinued on subsequent Classic Head designs and didn't make a reappearance until 1908.
courtesy Heritage Auctions
1909-D Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle: $480,000
This 1909-D Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle gold coin had a face value of just $20. However, an example sold for a stunning $480,000 at Heritage Auctions last month.
The recently sold specimen is tied for the second-finest known example of the coin. Only 52,000 of these rare coins were initially minted, and high-grade examples have remained undiscovered for decades. This impressive coin was from the famed Norweb Collection of 1988 (Part III).
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1931 low serial number $10 silver certificate bill: $500,000
Unlike many other low serial number bills, you won't see this beauty in circulation – if only! This 1931 $10 silver certificate, boasting the serial number A00000001A, has been valued by numismatic experts (or coin experts to you and me) at a cool $500,000.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1854 Deep Cameo Gold Dollar: $720,000
At its second-ever auction appearance in September this year, this 1854 Deep Cameo gold dollar sold for $720,000. Halfway through 1854, the Philadelphia Mint started producing Type 2 gold dollars. These were thinner and had a larger diameter than Type 1 coins, which many people complained were too difficult to locate in a pocket or purse. As a result, this example is one of the last Type 1 coins ever produced.
The dollar was previously sold at auction in 1985 when it was bought by collector Harry Bass for $68,750 – the equivalent of around $189,640 today.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1794 No Stars Flowing Hair dollar coin: $840,000
A prototype version of the US Mint's first dollar coin sold at Heritage Auctions in April last year for $840,000, way above its $350,000-$500,000 estimate.
The copper coin, known as a pattern, was reputedly discovered at the site of the first Philadelphia Mint back in the late 19th century. It's similar to the silver dollar coins that later went into circulation, bar the fact that it's missing the stars that appeared around the "flowing hair" portrait of Liberty. The coin was from the collection of Bob Simpson, the businessman and Texas Rangers co-chairman, who purchased it in 2008.
Courtesy Stack's Bowers Galleries
1792 Copper Disme: $900,000
"Expertly produced, carefully preserved, and visually appealing." That's how Stack's Bowers Galleries described this 1792 copper disme (the old term for a dime) when it came up for auction in August.
Featuring a bust of Liberty on one side and an eagle with spread wings on the other, the coin is the second-finest known example of its kind and can be traced back to before 1908. It sold for $900,000, a whopping 90 million times its face value of 10 cents!
courtesy Heritage Auctions
1924-S Double Eagle: $930,000
The 1924-S Double Eagle is widely regarded as one of the rarest American gold coins. In August, the finest example of one fetched $930,000 at Heritage Auctions, far more than its $20 face value.
Dubbed a "wonder coin," the 1924-S Double Eagle is described by experts as being "far superior" and better preserved than any other known example of the exceedingly rare coin.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1875 $10 Liberty: $1.02 million
Only 100 1875 $10 Liberty coins were struck by the Philadelphia Mint, making this an example of "the lowest mintage regular-issue U.S. gold coin," according to Heritage Auctions.
In October this year, one example (pictured) sold for $1.02 million, setting a new auction record. In fact, the final price when the hammer fell was almost three times as high as the coin's previous sale price of $372,000 back in 2018.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1792 Judd 13 white metal quarter: $1.26 million
At the same Heritage Auction sale as the previous entry, this 1792 pattern sold for a staggering £1.26 million. Experts believe the coin was made as a potential prototype for the quarter dollar coin. It's one of two examples owned by the New-York Historical Society, and one of just four known to be in existence. The Society found its pair of coins back in 2003, while taking an inventory of its coin and medal catalog.
Courtesy Legend Numismatics
1943-D Lincoln copper wheat penny coin: $1.7 million
While around two-dozen specimens of the Philadelphia-minted 1943 copper penny are known to exist, just one example struck at the Denver Mint has been discovered. As a result, the truly unique coin is worth an absolute fortune.
In fact, the penny, which was discovered for the very first time in 1979, was sold for a jaw-dropping $1.7 million by New Jersey's Legend Numismatics back in September 2010.
1907 Rolled Gold Edge Eagle $10 coin: up to $2.2 million
Very few 1907 Rolled Gold Edge Eagle $10 coins are known to be surviving today, and collectors have entered into fierce bidding wars to get their hands on these elusive coins.
One of the coins, referred to as the "finest example...known today," sold for $2.2 million at auction in January 2011. Over 6,700 people took part in the bidding war, which was hosted by Heritage Auctions in Tampa, Florida.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1854-S Liberty Half Eagle: $2.4 million
According to Heritage Auctions, just 268 examples of the 1854-S Liberty Half Eagle were minted, of which only four are known about today. When the coin was discovered by an anonymous New England collector in 2018, experts thought it might be one that was notoriously stolen from the collection of American banker Willis du Pont in 1967.
Tests later confirmed that it was a different coin, however, meaning it could be sold at auction. It fetched $2.16 million in 2018 and was sold again just three years later, netting a cool $2.4 million in its second-ever public offering in August last year.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1891 red seal $1,000 treasury note: $2.5 million
Setting what was then a world record for a rare banknote sale, this 1891 red seal $1,000 treasury note sold for an astonishing $2.5 million at auction in 2013, far exceeding its estimate value of $2 million.
One of two surviving specimens, the high denomination note is every collector's dream acquisition. It features a portrait of George Meade, the US military man who played a crucial role in the American Civil War.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1792 Birch penny coin: up to $2.6 million
Worth millions more than its face value, the very first penny struck by the United States Mint is the Holy Grail cent coin for collectors.
Nicknamed after its engraver Robert Birch, the "Birch Cent" is likely to have been handled by both George Washington and Thomas Jefferson, further adding to its prestige. With just 10 in existence, this particular coin was snapped up in 2015 for $2.6 million by delighted collector Kevin Lipton.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1890 Grand Watermelon $1,000 treasury note: $3.3 million
The super-rare and world-famous 1890 Grand Watermelon $1,000 treasury note exceeded all expectations when it fetched a staggering $3.3 million at auction in 2014, making it the world's most valuable banknote.
The bill is so named on account of the green zeros on the note's reverse, which have been likened to watermelons. Prior to this, the note was last sold at auction in 1970, when it went under the hammer for $11,000 ($79k in today's money).
Courtesy Stack's Bowers Galleries
1825 Capped Head Left Half Eagle $5 coin: $4.08 million
An 1825 Capped Head Left Half Eagle, the finest known proof of its kind, went under the hammer at Stack's Bowers Galleries in August this year. It was never recorded how many proofs were struck but just three are known to exist today, making this coin incredibly rare. After being off the market for around 50 years, it eventually sold for $4.08 million – nearly twice as much as its upper estimate, and over 800,000 times higher than its $5 face value.
Its sale price made it the most valuable pre-1834 American gold proof ever sold at auction, as well as the second-most valuable $5 gold coin of any kind.
courtesy Heritage Auctions
1927-D Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle: $4.4 million
A 1927-D Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle coin sold for an astounding $4.4 million at Heritage Auctions in August. Before you check your change, though, it's worth noting that just 14 examples of this ultra-rare coin have ever been traced.
The recently sold example fetched the highest ever sale price for the 1927-D Double Eagle, smashing the previous record of $2.16 million in 2020.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1821 Capped Head $5 coin: $4.62 million
This 1821 Capped Head $5 coin, the only proof in private hands, sold for an incredible $4.62 million at the end of September this year. Even though almost 35,000 copies of the coin were minted in 1821, proofs are rare, with only two examples known to exist, one of which is kept at the Smithsonian Institution.
Adding to its appeal, this particular example has a distinguished past and was once owned by the Egyptian King Farouk. As Heritage Auctions Vice President Todd Imhof put it: "This is an extraordinary coin that brought an extraordinary result."
1913 Liberty Head nickel coin: up to $5 million
Just five 1913 nickels bearing the Liberty Head design are still in existence – and they're highly valuable. Heritage Auctions sold one for $3.7 million in 2010 and another for $3.2 million in 2013. The most valuable example, the so-called Eliasberg Specimen, was purchased by a private collector from California for $5 million in 2007.
1794 Lord St Oswald-Norweb Flowing Hair dollar coin: $5 million
The highly covetable Flowing Hair dollar was the first dollar coin issued by the US federal government and is now the most coveted by collectors. This perfectly preserved specimen from the Lord St Oswald-Norweb Collection went for just under $5 million at auction in 2017. Prior to that, the ultra-rare coin sold in auction for $242,000 in 1988, the equivalent of $570k in today's money.
1804/1834 proof eagle $10 coin: up to $5.28 million
This exquisite $10 gold coin might bear the year 1804, but it was actually minted in 1834 for President Andrew Jackson to offer as a diplomatic gift to officials in Asia. Today, only four examples of the coin are known to exist, with one selling via Heritage Auctions for $5.28 million in January 2021.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1861 Paquet Double Eagle $20 coin: $7.2 million
Another multimillion-dollar coin that sold in 2021 is this 1861 Paquet Double Eagle coin, which was originally worth $20. It's been described as "by far the rarest regular issue Double Eagle," with only two examples known to exist. One of the coins sold for a whopping $7.2 million at Heritage Auctions last August. The gleaming coin is named after Anthony Paquet (1814-1882), who was an assistant engraver at the United States Mint.
1804/1830s Draped Bust dollar coin: up to $7.68 million
Described as "the King of American coins," only 15 examples of the 1804 Bust dollar – aka the Bowed Liberty dollar coin – are known to exist, and the finest Class I pieces command sky-high prices.
While they're dated 1804, the coins were actually struck during or after the 1830s. One specimen sold for $4.1 million in 1999, while another fetched $3.9 million at auction in 2013. Most recently, an example from the 1835 collection of the Sultan of Muscat sold for $7.68 million in August 2021.
1822 Capped Bust Half Eagle: $8.4 million
This 1822 Capped Bust Half Eagle briefly became the world's most valuable gold US coin when it sold for $8.4 million on 25 March 2021. According to the PCGS, the coin has only been sold a few times in the last century, with just three known examples in existence.
Unlike other entries on our list, however, this coin hasn't always been rare. Almost 18,000 copies of the coin were originally minted – so there are potentially more out there still waiting to be found.
Courtesy Heritage Auctions
1787 New York-Style Brasher Doubloon: $9.36 million
The finest example of just seven known 1787 New York-Style Brasher Doubloons, this gold coin hit the headlines in January 2021 when it sold for a huge $9.36 million via Heritage Auctions.
Discovered in 1848, this particular coin caused a storm as it has only been publicly sold twice since its first discovery, reaching record prices both times. Prior to the 2021 sale, it went for $725,000 in 1979, holding the record of the world's most valuable coin for a decade. While it might no longer be the world's most valuable coin, it certainly comes very close to the top spot.
1794 Carter Flowing Hair dollar coin: $10 million
Currently the world's second most valuable coin, this 1794 Flowing Hair Dollar is the finest known example. Described as a "national treasure" by numismatic expert Steven Contursi, the historically important coin sold for an almost unbelievable $10 million at auction in 2013. That's twice the amount paid for the previous Flowing Hair Dollar mentioned in our roundup.
1933 Double Eagle $20 coin: $18.9 million
An extremely rare Double Eagle coin sold for a record price of $18.9 million at a Sotheby's auction on 8 June last year. The coin now holds the record for the most expensive ever sold, more than doubling the previous record. Remarkably, the coin's face value is just $20. Its value is due to the fact that the 1933 edition never actually entered circulation, with most examples returned to and melted down by the US government. However, it's believed that 13 coins did make it into circulation, and in 1944 the Secret Service declared that if any collectors possessed any of the coins, they would be considered stolen.
This coin was only able to be sold by a private collector after a legal battle between the United States Treasury and a former owner of the coin, who was granted possession. The coin was then sold to the shoe designer Stuart Weitzman in 2002 for $7.6 million, which set a record at the time, before Weitzman put it up for sale again in 2021.
Now read about how the US dollar has changed over time