Then and Now: America’s oldest stores still open for business
The oldest stores in America

You might be surprised to learn that there are some stores in America which have been around for 100, 200 and even 300-plus years. These historic stores have weathered the storms over the years, from wars to recessions and more, yet they still manage to keep customers interested. What's more, they've even survived COVID-19 when many larger businesses are starting to crumble, and close stores. Click or scroll through to see the oldest stores in America and how much, or how little, they have changed.
Then: The Tavern, 1686

Now: The Tavern

The venerable liquor store sells beer, wine and spirits (including moonshine, of course), and specializes in small batch and local producers. Customers can stop by for tastings and get advice from staff in the original building.
Then: Moravian Book Shop, 1745

As well as being America’s oldest bookstore, the Moravian Book Shop in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, is also the oldest continuously-operating bookstore in not only the United States, but in the world. In 1745 the Moravian Church appointed a nearby inn to operate a bookstore. The store’s location changed several times until it moved to its current home in the church’s publications building near the Central Moravian Church (pictured) in 1871.
Now: Moravian Book Shop

Then: The Brick Store, 1790s

Now: The Brick Store

Then: Shreve, Crump & Low, 1796

Now: Shreve, Crump & Low

The jeweler’s storied past includes crafting many well-known cup trophies, and serving the needs of Hollywood’s most glamourous. In 1965 newlyweds Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton had their wedding rings engraved in the store while they waited. The current ownership has relocated to 39 Newbury Street, and there is also a store in Greenwich, Connecticut.
Then: Washington Trust, 1800

Now: Washington Trust

Then: Andover Bookstore, 1809

Now: Andover Bookstore

Today Phillips Academy students, parents and alumni can stop by to purchase apparel and other school merchandise in its newer location, or even online. The independently-owned bookstore, which is the second oldest in America, stocks everything from book bestsellers to toys, as well as used books, and offers community events like storytelling and book groups.
Then: Carl’s Drug Store, 1825

Now: Carl’s Drug Store

Then: C.O. Bigelow, 1838

Now: C.O. Bigelow

Then: Kiehl’s, 1851

Now: Kiehl’s

Then: Placerville Hardware, 1855

Now: Placerville Hardware

George Fausel purchased the store in 1952 and it has been in his family for the past three generations; Albert Fausel is now the current owner. In addition to offering all the staples of a hardware store, Placerville also rents metal detectors and says it offers the largest stock of gold panning supplies in the area.
Then: Alley's General Store, 1858

Now: Alley's General Store

In 1993 the Martha’s Vineyard Preservation Trust completely renovated the store, which, according to the Trust, remained an "emporium of the essentials and the fanciful.” However, a change in management and unexpected structutral, plumbing and electrical repairs meant the store closed for several months during the summer of 2021, though the post office stayed open. Residents welcomed the general store's reopening and it remains a staple of the community.
Then: Shane Confectionery, 1863

Now: Shane Confectionery

The Shane family continued making hand-crafted candies over the next 100 years until 2010 when Barry Shane sold the business to the Berley brothers, two young confectioners whose burgeoning candy business had been featured on the Food Network. They launched a grand reopening in 2011, and have since added a chocolate café in the store and expanded by opening an ice cream parlor.
America's most successful franchises that will make you want to invest
Then: Calef’s Country Store, 1869

Now: Calef’s Country Store

Today the building looks much the same and continues to sell traditional country store goods like sharp cheeses, honey, smoked ham and their own pumped molasses. The stores sources 90% of its food and gifts from New England companies, and customers across the region flock to its deli counter, and penny candy sold by the piece.
Then: Cochran Blair & Potts, 1869

Now: Cochran Blair & Potts

Then: Merz Apothecary, 1875

Now: Merz Apothecary

In 1982 Qaiyum moved the store to its current, larger location, which features leaded glass windows, tin ceilings and other custom-built details to replicate the styles of turn-of-the-century European apothecaries. The business has now expanded into online retail and opened an additional Chicago store including a boutique shop for men’s shaving products.
Then and now: America's oldest companies still open for business
Comments
Do you want to comment on this article? You need to be signed in for this feature