Auto-enrolment workplace pensions begin

With the NEST auto-enrolment workplace pensions kicking off, we look at exactly what it means for your retirement savings.
From today up to nine million employees will start being automatically enrolled into a pension scheme that will be linked to investments, such as shares, unless they choose to opt out. If you're one of them, your pay-packet will fall as you contribute to the pension, which is also paid into by your employer.
On top of that, the Government will add tax relief. When you start receiving an income from your pension at retirement you'll pay your taxes then, but you can expect to pay less in taxes overall this way.
Why is this happening?
The programme, called NEST (National Employment Savings Trust), is to get us to start taking more responsibility for saving for our retirement. The idea is to make 11 million future retirees, who aren't saving enough, less reliant on taxpayers and the largess of Government.
Taxpayers – especially future generations of taxpayers – gain by the same token, because they will need to pay less in benefits to retirees in decades to come, merely to give their parents and grandparents a basic standard of living.
Who will this affect?
You'll be automatically enrolled if you're at least 22 but under State Pension age and if you're earning more than £8,105.
When is this happening?
Employees will be auto-enrolled over the next few years, depending on the size of their employer.
The first wave of people will join schemes inside two weeks and the Government expects that 600,000 will be paying contributions into it by the end of the year. By 2015, it expects more than four million to be in the scheme, and the roll out will be finished by 2018.
The schedule is:
Number of employees |
Date of enrolment |
120,000 or more |
01/10/12 |
50,000-119,999 |
01/11/12 |
30,000-49,999 |
01/01/13 |
20,000-29,999 |
01/02/13 |
10,000-19,999 |
01/03/13 |
6,000-9,999 |
01/04/13 |
4,100-5,999 |
01/05/13 |
4,000-4,099 |
01/06/13 |
3,000-3,999 |
01/07/13 |
2,000-2,999 |
01/08/13 |
1,250-1,999 |
01/09/13 |
800-1,249 |
01/10/13 |
500-799 |
01/11/13 |
350-499 |
01/01/14 |
250-349 |
01/02/14 |
160-249 |
01/04/14 |
90-159 |
01/05/14 |
62-89 |
01/07/14 |
61 |
01/08/14 |
60 |
01/10/14 |
59 |
01/11/14 |
58 |
01/01/15 |
54-57 |
01/03/15 |
50-53 |
01/04/15 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 92, A1-A9, B1-B9, AA-AZ, BA-BW, M1-M9, MA-MZ, Z1-Z9, ZA-ZZ , 0A-0Z, 1A-1Z or 2A-2Z |
01/06/15 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference number BX |
01/07/15 |
40-49 |
01/08/15 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference number BY |
01/09/15 |
30-39 |
01/10/15 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference number BZ |
01/11/15 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 02-04, C1-C9, D1-D9, CA-CZ or DA-DZ |
01/01/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 00 05-07, E1-E9 or EA-EZ |
01/02/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 01, 08-11, F1-F9, G1-G9, FA-FZ or GA-GZ |
01/03/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 12-16, 3A-3Z, H1-H9 or HA-HZ |
01/04/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers I1-I9 or IA-IZ |
01/05/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 17-22, 4A-4Z, J1-J9 or JA-JZ |
01/06/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 23-29, 5A-5Z, K1-K9 or KA-KZ |
01/07/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 30-37, 6A-6Z, L1-L9 or LA-LZ |
01/08/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers N1-N9 or NA-NZ |
01/09/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 38-46, 7A-7Z, O1-O9 or OA-OZ |
01/10/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 47-57, 8A-8Z, Q1-Q9, R1-R9, S1-S9, T1-T9, QA-QZ, RA-RZ, SA-SZ or TA-TZ |
01/11/16 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 58-69, 9A-9Z, U1-U9, V1-V9, W1-W9, UA-UZ, VA-VZ or WA-WZ |
01/01/17 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 70-83, X1-X9, Y1-Y9, XA-XZ or YA-YZ |
01/02/17 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers P1-P9 or PA-PZ |
01/03/17 |
Fewer than 30 with the last 2 characters in their PAYE reference numbers 84-91, 93-99 |
01/04/17 |
Fewer than 30 unless otherwise described |
01/04/17 |
Employer who does not have a PAYE scheme |
01/04/17 |
New employer (PAYE income first payable between 1 April 2012 and 31 March 2013) |
01/05/17 |
New employer (PAYE income first payable between 1 April 2013 and 31 March 2014) |
01/07/17 |
New employer (PAYE income first payable between 1 April 2014 and 31 March 2015) |
01/08/17 |
New employer (PAYE income first payable between 1 April 2015 and 31 December 2015) |
01/10/17 |
New employer (PAYE income first payable between 1 January 2016 and 30 September 2016) |
01/11/17 |
New employer (PAYE income first payable between 1 October 2016 and 30 June 2017) |
01/01/18 |
New employer (PAYE income first payable between 1 July 2017 and 30 September 2017) |
01/02/18 |
Source: The Pensions Regulator
How much will my salary fall?
You can pay in extra in regular amounts or one-off contributions, but your employer will contribute out of its own pocket too.
Minimum contributions include payments from your employer, Government and yourself, and are based on your pre-tax earnings, excluding the first £5,564 and up to £42,475. These figures will be reviewed every year.
The minimum contributions will increase between now and 2018 as follows:
Date |
Minimum contributions |
Your contribution based on £15,000 salary |
Your contribution based on £30,000 salary |
Oct 2012-Sep 2017 |
2% Of this, you must pay at least 1% |
£7.90pm |
£20.40pm |
Oct 2017-Sep 2018 |
5% Of this, you must pay at least: 2% |
£15.70pm |
£40.70pm |
Oct 2018 onwards |
8% Of this, you must pay at least: 3% |
£23.60pm |
£61.10pm |
What might I get in the end, in today's prices?
In today's prices – which means deducting inflation – here's what you might expect to get from your pot, but please bear in mind these are just rough estimates, since we can't predict the future of your investments:
How long you save for |
£15,000 starting salary |
£22,000 starting salary |
£30,000 starting salary |
25 years |
£4,900 in up-front cash and £900 in private annual income |
£8,500 in up-front cash and £1,550 in private annual income |
£12,700 in up-front cash and £2,300 in private annual income |
35 years |
£8,000 in up-front cash and £1,450 in private annual income |
£14,000 in up-front cash and £2,550 in private annual income |
£20,900 in up-front cash and £3,750 in private annual income |
You could perhaps get a lot more if your salary leaps much faster than inflation, e.g. because of a big promotion.
These aren't huge amounts, but you'd hope that they'll nicely supplement State Benefits, and will mean you're less reliant on them. You and your employer can also contribute extra. Doing so in the earlier years in particular is likely to make a massive difference. Retiring later can also hugely increase your up-front cash and annual income.
What should I watch out for?
Costs, diversity and investment choice are the three main things most people should consider when investing.
NEST will work out at an annual charge of around 0.5% for most people, which is pretty good. Add on trading costs and the overall total will hopefully be less than 1%, which is also quite good.
It is certainly diverse, since your money will probably be invested across a wide range of assets. This will help protect you from a massive disaster in on asset, such as a single company going bust and you have half your money in it.
What can I invest in?
However, investment choice is not so good, and this is the third thing to watch out for. With the default fund – which most people don't bother changing – NEST is looking to be very cautious and to smooth out your progress, meaning no big highs or lows. The problem with this approach is, while it's reassuring in the short-term, you should expect it to mean a worse performance in the long run.
I have tried to take that into account with my projections in the section above, but I might have underestimated the impact of this smoothing action, depending on how cautious NEST will be. Time will tell.
The closer you are to retirement, the more cautious NEST will be, which makes sense. You can choose a handful of other funds: ethical, Sharia-compliant, higher risk, lower growth and pre-retirement funds. You can swap between funds at no cost, but be wary of jumping ship after a big fall and hundreds of scary news stories. This is almost always the worst time to do so.
Read How NEST will invest your compulsory pension.
Can I move other pensions into it?
At present, you can't transfer pensions into or out of NEST.
When can I take cash out of the plan?
Your money is locked in until the agreed end date, which is usually around your expected retirement date. Under current rules, you can then take 25% of your pot as tax-free cash and normally you'll then get a monthly income from the rest, guaranteed for the rest of your life.
You can only normally get all your money back straight away if you have been auto-enrolled and you opt out within one month of this happening.
Should I opt out?
It's a good idea to take as much control of your financial future as possible and, the earlier you do this, the better.
That said, if you're struggling with debt, it can make sense to put more money to paying that off.
In addition, consider share ISAs instead, due to the risks of Government tinkering with pensions. Governments can tinker with share ISAs too, but it's probably going to be easier to get all your money out of an ISA, if trouble comes.
Lower earners in particular might find that their contributions come to nothing, because it just means your benefits are reduced in retirement. Therefore you might opt out – although this is hard to predict and could turn out to be just as risky as not saving in a pension. The choice is simply not easy.
Will I be opted in again later?
If you opt out, you'll be automatically enrolled every three years unless you opt out again.
More on pensions:
No, you can't retire on £50,000!
Government reconsidering £140 State Pension plan
Auto-enrolment: pensions are getting better, but nobody knows it
New way to make sense of pensions jargon
Pensions: trust or contract?
What is a pension trustee?
Most Recent
Comments
-
This is by far the most detailed explanation I've read anywhere. I'm no longer employed, but pensions have changed beyond all recognition during my working life, and no doubt will continue to do so; a good thing too, but way to go yet. The main problem with both the State pension and the company/individual pension plans that I've had over the years is that in the early years, the contributions were far too small. The State graduated annuity benefit, which was compulsory, was supposedly a separate (graduated according to salary over the level for the NICs contribution) scheme which was supposed to add a bit extra to the basic State pension; later this morphed into Serps, and later still the State Second Pension, both of which could be opted-out from. With the first Serps, the Government/employer also contributed I think, and in the early days opting-out was certainly the best choice for younger people; later on the advantages were skewed more towards help for the lower-paid, and the rules were also changed so opting-in was a better choice for older people. Now we are all aware that we need to make better provision for ourselves, and have witnessed the various Government raids on the funds we thought we had built up, I think that Neil's suggestion of using an ISA investment vehicle is probably a better choice for most on low to average earnings. Not only can you access those funds in a real emergency if you have to, but I'm quite sure that when the flat-rate State pension in introduced, the existing benefits such as tax credits will be scrapped as a means of topping-up the State pension for the poorest; indeed, that must be why this new scheme is being introduced. Remember too that the extra tax allowance for pensioners is also being phased out, and ISA income is tax-free at the moment, whereas pensions are not. If the idea of a subsidy from other taxpayers on the way in to the pension fund appeals, you can always set up a low-cost SIPP via one of the providers of ISAs, using the same investments as in your ISA if you wish, and employers are allowed to contribute to these if you can persuade them to do so. At present, however, you need a fund of £100k in your pension pot to get around £5k out as an annuity if you use its flexibility to provide even quite modest add-ons, so unless you think you will have amassed considerably more than this when you qualify to take it, it may not be worth doing. However, if you have a really tiny fund, currently around £18k I think, you are allowed to take all of it at once; it may even be tax-free at present but do check because I'm not sure about that and even if it is, it's almost bound to change!
REPORT This comment has been reported. -
As I see it... We must opt out if we don't want to participate but we must also continue to opt out every 3 years. Surely no means no?! I expect eventually the ability to opt out will be withdrawn and this scheme will replace the state pension. It looks as though they've invented a new tax... The annual charges are low...for the moment. Look what happened to tuition fees, they start you off slowly to minimise the objections then ramp up. Once they have your money you can't get it until you retire and they can charge what they like whether your pension fund is up or down. It's obvious they're banking on public apathy for this to work but it's the Big Brother way of doing it that I object to. Given the track record of pensions in this country I would advise anyone to run a mile from this and make their own provisions for old age.
REPORT This comment has been reported. -
If the govt was serious about people saving for their pensions they could do two things. One, as a token of good faith, undo Gordon Browns raid on pensions, which has caused the pensions disaster in the first place. Two, provide some assurance that the money saved today (say a 20 year old retiring at the age of 70 = 50 years on), will not lose its value to the same extent that money has lost its value over the past 50 years.
REPORT This comment has been reported.
Do you want to comment on this article? You need to be signed in for this feature
02 October 2012