Top

I loathe these savings accounts!

Rachel Robson reveals five savings accounts you should avoid at all costs.

For the past two months the base rate has been held at 0.5%. Nothing terribly exciting about that, I hear you say.

But in my book, that means it's about time interest rates on savings accounts started to pick up.

Ok, ok, I know - banks and building societies are hardly going to start increasing their savings rates if the base rate hasn't gone up. But I think it's about time the savers among us were given a break. Would that really be such a crime?

Rubbish rates

Unfortunately, judging by the pathetic rates many savings accounts are offering, that's not going to be happening any time soon.

Recent research from Investec Private Bank has revealed that four out of ten savings accounts for balances of £1 are currently paying 0.1% or less in interest. For balances of £5,000, more than a quarter of savings accounts are now paying 0.1% or less, and for balances of £25,000, 22% of accounts are paying 0.1% or less.

Paints a pretty gloomy picture, doesn't it? So much so, that I wouldn't blame you for wondering whether there's any point in saving at all.

Five of the worst

To give you an example of just how bad some savings accounts are, in the chart below, I've highlighted five of the worst instant access savings accounts currently available:

Account and provider

Interest rate (AER)

Minimum deposit

Cumberland Building Society Cashcard Flexible Access Account

0%

£50 (or £1 if under 16)

Laiki Bank Instant Access Account

0%

£1

Bank of Ireland Card Saver Account

0.001%

£100

Newcastle Building Society Nova Plus Account (Issue 3)

0.01%

£1

First Direct Savings Account

0.05%

£1

That's right. Some of these accounts are paying nothing. Nothing! Zilch! Not a penny! How they dare to call themselves savings accounts, I don't know...

If, like me, you're not feeling tempted by these rates, beware. The list of savings accounts paying such pitiful interest rates goes on and on and on - and when was the last time you checked what your money was earning?

Frankly, if you've got an account paying less than 1%, I recommend you ditch it straightaway. You've got more chance of being rewarded for your saving efforts by stuffing your money under the mattress.

Five of the best

Before I send you further into the depths of despair, I'm going to restore your faith in saving and highlight some of the best instant access savings accounts available. Because believe it or not, it is still possible to get a good return on your savings.

Account and provider

Interest rate (AER)

Minimum deposit

Other

ING Direct Savings Account

2.75%

£1

Includes 12 month fixed bonus of 2.22%

Birmingham Midshires Access Reward Account Issue 4

2.75%

£1,000

Telephone access only.

Only 4 withdrawals permitted in first year.

Capital One Flexi Saver Issue 1

2.65%

£500

Includes 12 month variable bonus of 1%

Sainsbury's Finance Internet Saver

2.60%*

£5,000

Rate drops to 0.75% you make a withdrawal, or your account falls below £5,000 in the first year

Egg Savings Account (Internet)

2.50%

£1

Includes 12 month variable bonus of 1.25%

*Interest rate guaranteed to be at least 2% above the Bank of England base rate for 12 months from your account opening date. Apply before 8 June.

In my opinion the ING Direct Savings Accounts knocks the socks off the competition. Not only does it offer an attractive 2.75% interest rate, but it includes a 12 month fixed bonus of 2.22% - so you can be reassured the rate won't drop below this level for the first year at least.

What's more, you'll only need £1 to open the account and there are no penalties for withdrawals. This compares favourably to the Birmingham Midshires account which only allows you to make four withdrawals in the first year. Not exactly what I would call easy access.

The Sainsbury's Finance Internet Saver also comes with a few strings attached. For a start you'll need a fairly hefty sum of £5,000 to open the account. And secondly the interest rate drops to a measly 0.75% if you make a withdrawal in the first year - rubbish!

That said, if you can afford to leave your money untouched for the first year, the interest rate on the account is guaranteed to be at least 2% above the base rate - which is a pretty attractive incentive in the current market. And the account also gets the thumbs up when it comes to consistency

Don't delay, switch today!

Savings rates are still a long way off from the impressive 6% and 7% we saw a year ago. And many rates out there are simply not worth having at all.

But as I've revealed, it is still possible to get a decent return on your savings if you know where to look. So if you've got any money lurking in a savings account paying a rate of next to nothing, don't put up with it! Switch to a higher paying account today and reap the rewards.

More: Earn a top guaranteed rate on your savings | Good news for Lehman victims

Most Recent


Comments


  • I agree with the comments about ING- their rate for 'old' customers is cr@*!! And yes, they're foreign! But even more important- and this hasn't been mentioned anywhere... what happens when you want to get your money out? Guess what. It 'disappears' for three or four days, or five if you ask for it to be transferred on a Wednesday and then it doesn't appear in your bank account until the following Monday because of the weekend which just happens to get in between the second and third 'working days'!!! This is because, whilst they are proud to tell you that you can transfer money IN from another account, e.g. your bank, via the new 'faster payments' system, whereby your money appears instantaneously and you don't lose any interest, THEY DO NOT OPERATE THIS WAY WHEN YOU TAKE YOUR MONEY BACK OUT! It might not make a lot of difference whilst interest rates are so low, but when they get back up to 4% or more and you want, say, £10,000 out for something in a hurry, its a different matter. When interest rates are at 5% per annum then losing interest on £10,000 for five days will cost you £6.69. OK perhaps its not a fortune, but why should they keep YOUR interest when there IS a system available which prevents this age-old banker's rip off from being inflicted on all those unwitting customers who think that's just the way it works and there's nothing to be done about it! Especially when they do use it to get your money IN to their accounts in the first place. "Nobody got rich by giving things away" is an old saying that springs to mind. So don't let them take it off you if you don't have to either! Egg work just the same way as ING, and I imagine lots of others do to. (Of course Egg are owned by Citibank, in other words they're foreign too!). Tesco internet saver account however uses the 'Faster Payments' system when you want your money out. I find this really handy as I don't have to worry about thinking whether I need any money for the weekend before Friday, and as long as I do my transfer before 6.30 pm then my money will be where I need it and no sneeky costs to worry about in the form of lost interest! So whoever you choose (I'm not just pushing Tesco but they're still right up there at 2.5% per annum including 1% bonus for the first 12 months) MAKE SURE YOU CAN GET AT YOUR MONEY INSTANTLY... THAT MEANS TODAY AND NOT AFTER 3 WORKING DAYS TO CLEAR!!!

    REPORT This comment has been reported.
    3

  • 18 May 2009

    Yorkshire BS should get a mention. On-line is 2.1% but fully flexible and no introductory rates etc. Those lised above have a 12 month bonus, drops for withdrawls etc.

    REPORT This comment has been reported.
    3

  • 18 May 2009

    Anyone daft enough not to periodically check the interest rate on their existing accounts or when opening a new account deserves these appalling rates!!

    REPORT This comment has been reported.
    3

Do you want to comment on this article? You need to be signed in for this feature

Most Popular

Copyright © lovemoney.com All rights reserved.

 

loveMONEY.com Financial Services Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) with Firm Reference Number (FRN): 479153.

loveMONEY.com is a company registered in England & Wales (Company Number: 7406028) with its registered address at First Floor Ridgeland House, 15 Carfax, Horsham, West Sussex, RH12 1DY, United Kingdom. loveMONEY.com Limited operates under the trading name of loveMONEY.com Financial Services Limited. We operate as a credit broker for consumer credit and do not lend directly. Our company maintains relationships with various affiliates and lenders, which we may promote within our editorial content in emails and on featured partner pages through affiliate links. Please note, that we may receive commission payments from some of the product and service providers featured on our website. In line with Consumer Duty regulations, we assess our partners to ensure they offer fair value, are transparent, and cater to the needs of all customers, including vulnerable groups. We continuously review our practices to ensure compliance with these standards. While we make every effort to ensure the accuracy and currency of our editorial content, users should independently verify information with their chosen product or service provider. This can be done by reviewing the product landing page information and the terms and conditions associated with the product. If you are uncertain whether a product is suitable, we strongly recommend seeking advice from a regulated independent financial advisor before applying for the products.