Cheap runners: cars most and least likely to pass an MOT test

New data reveals which cars are most likely to pass an MOT and those most likely to fail.
Taking your car for a MOT is a stressful experience, no matter what car you have or how long you’ve had it.
But the truth is that your experience can differ sharply depending on precisely what you drive.
After all, while some cars have a fantastic record at passing the test, others have a patchier record.
Now leasing comparison site LeaseLoco has dug into data obtained from the DVSA through a Freedom of Information request to pick out which cars perform best in the tests, and which have room for improvement.
Servicing: car brands with the most satisfied drivers
The best and worst car models
First, let’s take a look at the individual car models with the best pass record in 2023.
Importantly the breakdown focuses only on those cars where there were at least 1,000 MOTs carried out across the year.
Car |
Number of MOTs (2023) |
Number of passes |
Number of fails |
Pass rate |
Lexus UX |
1,195 |
1,140 |
55 |
95.4% |
Lexus RX |
1,231 |
1,153 |
78 |
93.7% |
Porsche Macan |
2,986 |
2,790 |
196 |
93.4% |
Ford Puma |
1,493 |
1,394 |
99 |
93.4% |
Volkswagen T-Cross |
1,816 |
1,667 |
149 |
91.8% |
Audi Q2 |
14,301 |
13,106 |
1,195 |
91.6% |
Lexus NX |
4,692 |
4,295 |
397 |
91.5% |
Volkswagen T-Roc |
15,352 |
13,964 |
1,388 |
91.0% |
Jaguar I-Pace |
1,532 |
1,391 |
141 |
90.8% |
Skoda Karoq |
8,484 |
7,702 |
782 |
90.8% |
The first thing that jumps out from this list is the performance of Lexus, which accounts for three of the 10 motors with the best pass record.
Indeed with Porsche, Audi and Jaguar also making the list there’s apparently some benefit to opting for a premium manufacturer.
Now let’s take a look at those with the worst pass records:
Car |
Number of MOTs (2023) |
Number of passes |
Number of fails |
Pass rate |
Peugeot 307 |
5,521 |
2,664 |
2,857 |
48.3% |
Citroen Xsara |
3,061 |
1,481 |
1,580 |
48.4% |
Renault Grand Scenic |
1,271 |
640 |
631 |
50.4% |
Peugeot 207 |
46,623 |
23,587 |
23,036 |
50.6% |
Volkswagen Beetle |
1,870 |
965 |
905 |
51.6% |
Hyundai Getz |
2,765 |
1,438 |
1,327 |
52.0% |
Volkswagen Fox |
4,792 |
2,512 |
2,280 |
52.4% |
Ford Focus C-Max |
1,867 |
981 |
886 |
52.5% |
Peugeot 206 |
11,521 |
6,609 |
5,452 |
52.7% |
Renault Megane |
19,574 |
10,336 |
9,238 |
52.8% |
Clearly, a pass rate of around one in two is absolutely brutal. Peugeot is a regular name here, with three of the models in the list, while Volkswagen and Renault have two each.
Ford is the only manufacturer to have a model in both the top and bottom list.
Save up to £269 on your car insurance with MoneySuperMarket
The best and worst manufacturers for MOT passes
However, those are only isolated examples. What about when you take a manufacturer’s entire line and see how they perform consistently across MOT tests?
These are the five names with the best and worst records according to LeaseLoco’s analysis, and it once again highlights the fact that you do get a little more reliability with a premium name.
Manufacturer |
Pass rate |
Manufacturer |
Pass rate |
Ferrari |
89.9% |
Citroen |
64.9% |
Bentley |
89.6% |
Alfa Romeo |
64.2% |
Aston Martin |
89.5% |
Renault |
63% |
Porsche |
88.9% |
Chrysler |
62.2% |
Lexus |
87.7% |
Chevrolet |
55.4% |
Improving your chances of passing
Unfortunately, this research doesn’t tell us precisely why these motors have come up short in the MOT tests.
But there are certain common reasons for failures that you can act on before heading off to the test to boost your chances of a pass.
For example, an awful lot of cars each year fail their MOT because the windscreen wiper doesn’t clear the screen properly.
All the testers are looking for is that the wipers can clear water quickly without leaving any untouched areas or smears, which will damage your visibility.
This can easily be avoided by testing your wipers properly at home, well in advance of the test. And getting substandard wipers replaced will work out at a fraction of the cost of having multiple MOTs.
Another very common reason for failure is your headline amp being out of alignment, and again it’s something you can check at home.
Line your car up with the beams on against a wall or garage door and mark where the centre of the beams is. Then reverse back a few metres and check the centre of the beam remains in the same place and that they are level.
Get breakdown cover with the AA from £7.50 a month
Most Recent
Comments
-
Most cars fail on stupid things that can be checked by the owner - wiper blades, tyre tread and condition, lights not working properly. Certain models are known for weaknesses - Vauxhall Corsas and Renault Clios for CV boots - Ford Ka and Nissan Micras for the strut top mounts due to the design of the Macpherson strut. Smaller hatchbacks that have a Macpherson strut, which is the spring/coil around the shock absorber, rather than the two being separate, are more likely to suffer from broken springs. Renault, Ford, VW (Polos more than Golfs) and Vauxhall being the likely candidates. Most MOT failures say more about the owner than the car manufacturer.
REPORT This comment has been reported. -
WTF does this mean? "Another very common reason for fails is your headline amp being out of alignment, " I think someone's spell checker has just failed it's MOT
REPORT This comment has been reported. -
It's also worth remembering that it's not just the car make or model that makes it unreliable &/or likely to fail an MoT, but it also depends how the car is driven & maintained (or not, as the case often is these days...)
REPORT This comment has been reported.
Do you want to comment on this article? You need to be signed in for this feature
08 June 2020